Three letters at the foot of a quotation can shape a dispute worth a great deal of money. The problem is not using Incoterms. It is treating them as a formatting habit rather than a description of the transaction.
Costs and risk follow different paths
ICC Academy explains that under CIP Incoterms® 2020 the seller arranges and pays for carriage and insurance to the agreed destination, while risk transfers on delivery to the carrier at the relevant point. The paid destination and risk-transfer point need not coincide. [1]
Sales and logistics should be able to identify both on the same map. One team may be describing arrival and the other collection while mistakenly believing they agree.
CIF and CIP do not require the same default cover
ICC identifies Institute Cargo Clauses (C) as the default insurance level for CIF under Incoterms® 2020, while CIP calls for Clauses (A) or equivalent cover. Different arrangements can be agreed and should be documented. CIF is for sea and inland-waterway transport. [2]
These differences do not establish that a particular policy covers every event. Check the insurance actually arranged, the insured interest and any exclusions or additional conditions.
Illustration: machinery on a multimodal journey
A company sells machinery for an overseas factory. Its quotation says CIP followed by the destination address. The sales manager assumes the seller retains every cargo risk until arrival. Before dispatch, review the agreed delivery point to the carrier, the insurance certificate and the sale contract together.
This illustration does not determine liability in an actual dispute. It reveals an expectation gap that can be corrected before the journey starts.
One record for three departments
Create a shipment record stating:
- The Incoterms rule, edition and precise named place.
- The operational delivery point relevant to risk transfer.
- Who must arrange insurance and the document confirming it.
- Insured interest, value, route and claims contact.
- Additional agreements requiring review before order acceptance.
The record is a coordination tool, not a substitute for contracts. Use it to find inconsistencies between the quotation, order, logistics instructions and insurance before separate departments implement different versions of the deal.
The TARGA check
Choose a recent sale. Ask sales, logistics and finance separately when the buyer starts bearing the cargo risk. Compare their answers with the documents.
Three conflicting answers do not necessarily mean three risks. They may mean one risk misunderstood three times.
Sources and references
- https://academy.iccwbo.org/incoterms/article/incoterms-2020-cpt-or-cip/
- https://iccwbo.org/business-solutions/incoterms-rules/incoterms-2020/
General professional insight. Individual situations require a review of documents and specific circumstances.
Put these questions to work.
Start with your operations, contracts and policy wording.
Talk to Saverio ↗